Auto repair leads are the drivers who ask your shop about a repair, and auto repair lead generation is the work of deciding where those requests come from. A shop can build its own sources or pay a seller for requests. Here is what a seller counts as a lead, what to ask before you pay, and what to fill in first.
A lead is a request, not a booked job
One driver’s call, text, voicemail or form is one lead. A booked job is a lead your shop turned into an appointment, and a repair is a booked job the driver kept. Those three counts differ, and the gap between them is where a shop’s advertising money goes.
The agency ClicksGeek, which sells lead generation to shops, says most auto repair shops “aren’t suffering from too few leads” and are “suffering from the wrong ones.” That is an agency’s claim about its own market. It still points at the right question: does the lead you got turn into a car in your bay?
What a bought lead is: Google’s version
Google’s Local Services Ads are one pay-per-lead product, and Google writes its billing rules down. On how leads work: “With Local Services Ads, you pay for valid leads.” The page lists what counts as valid, including these:
- You answer a phone call, or call the customer back and speak with them
- “You missed a phone call during your business hours and the customer stays on the line for more than 20 seconds.”
- You receive a text message or email from the customer
- You receive a voicemail from the customer
So a call you miss can still be a lead you pay for. Google adds that “Leads are first assessed when the potential customer makes initial contact, and leads determined to be invalid or low quality are not charged.” On price it gives no number: “Lead prices may vary depending on your location, the job type, the type of lead, or your bidding mode.”
Credits work after the fact. Google’s page on automated lead credits says “In most cases, credits will be applied to your account balance within 30 days.” It also says “the original lead charge will still appear on your invoice.”
This page did not check whether auto repair is open to you in your area, and it gives no lead price from any seller. Get both from the seller’s own page, and write down the date you read it.
Questions to ask any lead seller
Take Google’s rules as the standard and ask the seller to match them in writing:
- What makes a lead billable? Google counts a call you miss during your business hours when the caller stays on the line for more than 20 seconds. Ask what this seller’s rule is.
- Is a repeat caller billed again? Google says its systems filter out “spam or duplicate contacts.” Ask whether the seller does the same.
- Can I get a credit, and when? Google gives automatic credits, in most cases within 30 days. Ask for the seller’s terms.
- Does this driver also contact other shops? Google names this among the factors in a message lead’s price: “Whether the customer has contacted other Local Services advertisers.” Ask any seller if the lead comes to you alone.
- What is the price, and where does it say so? Keep the page address and the date beside the number.
Count cost per booked job
Cost per lead hides the part you care about. ClicksGeek gives this example: “A channel with a $15 CPL that books 20% of inquiries is more expensive than a channel with a $30 CPL that books 60% of inquiries.” CPL there means cost per lead. By its numbers, the first source costs $75 for each booked job and the second costs $50. The figures are the agency’s illustration, not a market average.
To count your own, write one line for each request: the date, how the driver found you, and whether it became an appointment. Tekmetric, a repair shop software company, gives a way to fill the second column: “Every time a new customer comes in, it’s good practice to ask them, ‘How did you hear about us?’” After a month, divide what you spent on each source by the jobs it booked.
Sources your shop already owns
Google’s page on local ranking tips is blunt: “There’s no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google.” What it does name is information and reviews. It says “Businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local search results,” and “More reviews and positive ratings can help your business’s local ranking.” Filling in your hours, services and phone number is work you do yourself, with no lead fee.
Your past customers are the other source you own. Shopmonkey, another shop software company, wrote in May 2024 that “no automotive repair shop can survive without bringing in new business.” Its first step is to re-contact the customers you already have. Our auto repair advertising ideas put the free and paid options in order of what they cost to try, and Yelp ads for auto repair shops covers one paid network.
The lead you lose after it arrives
A lead that nobody answers is paid for and wasted. Chris Shamis, owner of Dakota Ridge Auto, said in a 2016 Ratchet+Wrench article: “Answering a phone correctly should be the easiest way to gain new customers.” Of callers who get an answer that does not give them confidence, Shamis said they “might say, ‘OK, I’ll call you back,’” and “you’ve lost that opportunity with that customer.” Our guide on how fast to reply to leads covers the timing side, and our auto repair answering service guide covers the calls that come in while you are under a car.
SvarKlar answers your calls and messages, and a caller it misses gets a text back within seconds. A reply gives the caller a next step, but does not guarantee a booking. A person checks every reply until it gets them right. What an AI receptionist costs is on its own page.
Fill in your Google profile, call your past customers, and answer every request that reaches you. Then judge any seller by what a booked job costs you: in ClicksGeek’s own example, $75 for one source and $50 for another.
Want to see how SvarKlar would answer your shop’s calls? Book a call or see how the service works.